Natural resources-based conflicts are sometimes made complex by non-climate push and pull factors, like unemployment and political tension. These factors should be taken into account when developing and implementing a peacebuilding strategy, making sure all stakeholders are at the table – including those fueling the conflict. The online workshop ‘Integrating peacebuilding and climate change mitigation efforts in natural resource management’, organised by the European Peacebuilding Liaison Office (EPLO) and adelphi, looked into this complex issue.
In Marsabit County, Kenya, local communities have experienced changes in weather patterns, with reduced rain seasons and increased drought. Prolonged drought has led to scarcity in resources (mainly pasture and water) creating a shift in pastoral communities’ mobility patterns. The search for scarce resources increases inter-communal tensions and competition over access and control of depleting resources, which – if not well managed – often results in violent conflicts.
The local adaptive capacity of communities to climate change-related shocks, as well as social cohesion between communities need to be strengthened. To this end, World Vision Kenya's programme IMARA (Integrated MAnagement of natural Resources for resilience in Arid and semi-arid lands), is:
Natural resources-based conflicts (over water, pasture and land-use) are sometimes made complex and multifaceted by non-climate push and pull factors, like unemployment, political tension, rising violent extremism, etc. These factors should be analysed and taken into account when developing and implementing a peacebuilding strategy, recognising the role of government in making sure all stakeholders are at the table – including those fueling the conflict. During peace meetings, relevant authorities should be present too (authorities responsible for unemployment, resources management, etc.) in order to ensure that these issues are addressed.
Cordaid’s work on resilience demonstrates that there is a need for an integrated approach, combining disaster risk reduction, climate adaptation, ecosystem and natural resource management, peacebuilding – and any other relevant sectors / stakeholders. Doing a conflict (risk) analysis, in addition to a participatory disaster risk analysis, has been found to be a crucial first step to enhance resilience in fragile and conflict-affected areas. A participatory risk analysis and joint action planning at the beginning of a project ensure the participation of different groups, including the marginalised ones (youth, women, ethnic minorities, people with disabilities, etc.). Through a vulnerability assessment, the most vulnerable households can be identified and targeted in the programming.
Sustainability of peace and climate change initiatives at the community level can best be achieved through strengthening local institutions that include women and youth leaders able to prevent and manage conflict on their own without external support. Young men (morans) are the primary actors of conflicts since they are responsible for the search of pasture and water during dry season. They should be actively involved in climate change adaptation and peacebuilding initiatives.
When it comes to resolving conflict and building peace, the traditional approach (informal) involves elders coming together to discuss and resolve an issue. It is important to recognise and integrate this indigenous knowledge and mechanism into the more formal approach of the government when planning peace meetings together with the communities. These traditional institutions are most of the time dominated by men, when men and women experience climate change-related shocks and effects of conflicts differently.
There is need to give women more opportunities for decision making, empowering them to know their rights, feel supported and secure to have their voices heard without fear and intimidation. Their participation in meetings should not just ‘tick another box’, but reflect their active and meaningful participation in discussions, ensuring that their needs are recognised as being different from the men’s, and addressed. While gender is often mainstreamed and cross cutting, it also needs to be dealt as a standalone issue. The government budget and policy processes should reflect that, with enough resources allocated to specific programme activities that strengthen capacity building, and alternative and income-generating livelihoods for women and marginalised groups.
Natural resource-based conflict is a coping strategy for communities to respond to climate change-related shocks. Conflict is not a bad thing per se – it only becomes a bad thing when it turns into violence. Conflict can also be a key driver of change when used to cement inter-community interaction through integrating peacebuilding initiatives with resilience and climate change adaptation programming.
This blog post, originally posted on the EPLO Blog, was written in the framework of the online workshop ‘Integrating peacebuilding and climate change mitigation efforts in natural resource management’, as part of the online learning and exchange series ‘Climate change, peacebuilding and human security’ organised by the European Peacebuilding Liaison Office (EPLO), together with adelphi and the Climate Diplomacy initiative, with support from the German Federal Foreign Office.
The longstanding dispute over water rights among Egypt, Sudan and Ethiopia escalated in 2011 when Ethiopia began construction of the Grand Ethiopian Renaissance Dam (GERD), in the absence of any agreement with downstream Egypt. The GERD dispute offers an alarming insight into just how dangerous future transboundary water disputes may become, particularly in the context of a changing climate.
Coinciding with the first days the German Presidency of the European Council, on 3 July 2020 adelphi and the Institute for European Studies at the Vrije Universiteit Brussel launched a new report “The Geopolitics of Decarbonisation: Reshaping European Foreign Relations”. This summary highlights the event's key outcomes.
Women in the region suffer disproportionately from climate impacts, but they also play an essential role in addressing climate change. With the right policy responses, it is possible to reduce security risks and empower women to better address the challenges they face.
The impact of climate change is posing a growing threat to peace and security. Germany is therefore putting climate and security on the Security Council’s agenda.